“Which would be worse, to live as a monster, or to die as a good man?”
Martin Scorsese has never made a bad movie. That’s the kind of Scorsese fan I am. I truly believe that. And even when I don’t necessarily love a Scorsese movie, like, say After Hours, or New York, New York, I blame myself, not Saint Marty. Or, in the case of New York, New York, I blame his coke dealer. But I firmly believe he’s one of the greatest film makers of all time. I even love Gangs of New York. Yeah, I said it.
Even when you ignore the hallowed classics, like Taxi Driver, or Raging Bull, or Goodfellas, the middle ground stuff by Scorsese standards, is still better than almost any other movie you’ll ever see. So when I call Shutter Island middle ground, it’s only when using Scorsese as his own measuring stick. Because in the big scheme of things, Shutter Island is first class horror, suspense, psychological thriller stuff. (more…)